Marlborough, MA — 2026-11-21

Critical-Thinking Author Turns the Tables on a Fake BBC Radio 2 Invitation That Asked Him to Pay £197

Bo Bennett, PhD, author of Logically Fallacious, answered the "production contribution" by asking for $2,500 of his own. The sender replied, "Send the payment link." His company has published a free guide to spotting pay-to-appear interview scams.


MARLBOROUGH, Mass. — When an invitation to be interviewed by a well-known BBC Radio 2 presenter arrived on November 20, Bo Bennett, PhD, an author, publisher and social psychologist who writes about faulty reasoning, did what he tells his readers to do. He checked. What he found was a pay-to-appear scam, and he is now sharing how it worked so that other authors and experts can recognise the next one.

It began with a request signed with the presenter's name on MentionMatch, a service that passes journalists' requests for expert comment to experts. Bennett answered it with a short summary of his background. About ninety minutes later an invitation arrived from a Gmail address built to look like a BBC one, with the station's name and the BBC's web domain typed in front of "@gmail.com". It praised the very background he had just sent, offered three interview times, and said the show did not charge a fee for the interview itself, though "a small production contribution" applied.

Asked for the amount, the sender said it was £197, invoiced in advance and mandatory: "we would not be able to proceed with the interview without it." Bennett replied that he would be honoured to take part, and that he asks a contribution of his own, $2,500, paid in full before the interview. The sender said it could not pay that, asked him to do the interview for free instead, and, when he declined, wrote: "Send the payment link."

No interview took place and no money changed hands. Bennett's office sent a summary of the exchange to the presenter at the BBC and reported the request to MentionMatch.

"Legitimate podcasts and radio shows don't ask their guests for money," Bennett said. "If an invitation turns into an invoice, you were never being invited. You were being sold something by someone who had already lied about who they are."

It was not the first such approach. Since August, Bennett has received at least four similar invitations from Gmail addresses presenting themselves as podcast hosts. Asked about money, one quoted a $305 "production investment," and another sent a guest form asking for "contributions" of $215 to $750.

"These invitations work on capable, busy people because they use the same persuasion techniques I write about," Bennett said. "There is borrowed authority, in a famous name and a familiar station. There is flattery, made from your own words. And the cost comes last, after you've already pictured yourself on air."

Bennett recommends five checks before accepting any interview invitation:

1. Compare the sender's address with the outlet's own. Find the outlet's website yourself and see what domain its staff write from. A free email address with a broadcaster's name typed in front of the @ is not the broadcaster. 2. Write to the contact the outlet publishes and ask whether the invitation is theirs. 3. Before giving a date, ask in writing whether there is any cost to the guest, and whether it is mandatory. A genuine show answers no in one line. 4. Search the exact sender address. Scam addresses are reused, and other authors may already have posted about it. 5. Ask a past guest of the show, through their own website, whether they were asked to pay.

Anyone who has already paid should contact their card issuer or bank about disputing the charge, keep every email, and report the request to the service it came through. In the United States, fraud can also be reported to the Federal Trade Commission at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.

Bennett draws a clear line between an invitation and a service. His company runs AIHosts.fm, a podcast network on which every host is an AI and every guest is a real person. Guests sign up themselves, the first interview is free, and the prices of its paid plans are published on the site. "There is nothing wrong with paying for a service when you know you're buying one and can see the price up front," he said. "The scam is a sales pitch dressed up as an invitation."

The full guide, with the warning signs and the five checks, is free at aihosts.fm/podcast-guest-scams.

Bennett is available for interviews on how pay-to-appear scams target authors and experts, how to check an invitation, and the persuasion techniques these approaches rely on.

About Bo Bennett, PhD

Bo Bennett holds a PhD in social psychology and is the author of Logically Fallacious, a guide to faulty reasoning. He founded the self-publishing service eBookIt.com and Archieboy Holdings, LLC.

About Archieboy Holdings

Archieboy Holdings, LLC, of Marlborough, Massachusetts, runs publishing, marketing and software services, including eBookIt.com and AIHosts.fm, a podcast network with AI hosts and real human guests. Its team directory is at archieboy.com/about.

Media contact: Bo Bennett, partnerships@archieboy.com


Press contact: Bo Bennett · partnerships@archieboy.com
Published with PitchBud — personalized PR for the journalists who actually cover your beat.